A client recently came to our firm after relocating from Florida. He wanted to set up a “transfer-on-death deed” for his new apartment on the Upper West Side, a simple tool he had used for his previous home. I had to deliver some surprising news: in New York, that instrument does not exist for real property. While many states have adopted this probate-avoidance shortcut, our state has not. This is a critical distinction that, if overlooked, can unravel an otherwise well-intentioned estate plan.
Clients often hear about these deeds—sometimes called beneficiary deeds—and assume they are a universal tool. The idea is appealing: sign a deed now that only becomes effective upon your death, transferring your home directly to a child or other heir without involving the courts. It sounds clean. But relying on a legal tool that is not recognized here means the deed is invalid. When the time comes, the property will almost certainly be forced into a lengthy and public probate process in Surrogate’s Court—the very outcome the owner tried to prevent.
The New York Approach to Transferring Real Estate
Since a transfer-on-death deed is not an option for property in New York, we rely on established, predictable methods to achieve the same goal. The aim is a seamless transition of ownership that honors your wishes and minimizes court intervention. In my practice, this involves one of two primary strategies: a revocable living trust or a deed with survivorship rights.
A revocable living trust is often the most prudent and flexible instrument for managing significant assets like real estate. When you create a trust, you retitle your property into the name of the trust. You still control it completely during your lifetime as the trustee. You can sell it, mortgage it, or rent it out. Upon your death, a successor trustee you appointed steps in to manage the property and distribute it to your named beneficiaries according to the trust’s instructions. The entire process happens privately, outside of Surrogate’s Court.
Stewardship. This is about more than just avoiding probate. A trust allows for sophisticated contingency planning. What if your chosen beneficiary is a minor, has special needs, or is not financially responsible? A trust can hold the property for their benefit, managed by a fiduciary who has a legal duty to act in their best interests. A simple deed transfer cannot offer this level of protection.
Understanding Deeds with Rights of Survivorship
The other common method is to hold title to the property jointly with another person. New York law recognizes two main forms of co-ownership that include an automatic right of survivorship: Joint Tenancy with Rights of Survivorship (JTWROS) and, for married couples, Tenancy by the Entirety.
When property is held this way, the surviving owner automatically inherits the entire property upon the death of the other owner. The transfer is immediate and happens by operation of law, no probate required. While this sounds simple, it comes with significant risks that a trust avoids.
First, adding someone to your deed as a joint tenant is an irrevocable gift. You are giving away a portion of your property now. This means you can no longer sell or refinance the property without their consent. Second, the property becomes exposed to the joint owner’s creditors. If they are sued, face a divorce, or file for bankruptcy, your home could be at risk.
The law is very specific about how these deeds must be worded. Under New York’s Real Property Law § 240-c, a deed to two or more unmarried people is presumed to create a “tenancy in common”—which has no right of survivorship—unless the deed “expressly declares” the intent to create a joint tenancy. Getting this language wrong can void the entire survivorship plan.
A Deliberate Choice, Not a Shortcut
The desire for a simple “deed of death transfer” is understandable. People want to make things easy for their families. But in estate planning, the simplest-sounding option is not always the most effective or the safest. The lack of a transfer-on-death deed in our state is not an oversight; it reflects a legal tradition that favors more deliberate and protective methods of transferring generational wealth.
A home or investment property is often a family’s most significant asset. Its transfer should be handled with intentionality, not with a tool that our courts do not recognize. Using a trust or a carefully considered joint tenancy ensures your legacy is passed on as you wish, without creating a legal crisis for the people you intend to protect.
Before you consider any changes to your property’s title, a prudent first step is to have the current deed reviewed. We can audit your real estate deeds to clarify how your property would be handled under your current plan and discuss more effective instruments for your legacy.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.
