I once worked with three siblings in Brooklyn who had just lost their mother. She left behind a paid-off brownstone, but no will. One son, who lived on the second floor, wanted to stay. His sister, living in California, wanted to sell immediately and take her share of the cash. The third sibling wanted to keep it as a rental property for income. Within weeks, a family grieving together was on the verge of suing one another. Their mother’s most significant asset had become their most significant conflict.
This is a story I’ve seen play out many times. The family home is more than just an asset on a balance sheet—it’s a place of memory and identity. When a parent passes away, the question of who inherits the house is not just a legal one; it is deeply personal. The answer depends entirely on the plan a parent put in place—or failed to.
The Will as the Deciding Document
The most straightforward scenario is when a parent leaves a valid will. The will is a direct instruction to the executor and to the Surrogate’s Court about who should receive the property. It is the parent’s final act of stewardship for the assets they built over a lifetime.
A will can be very specific. For example, it might state:
- “I give my home to my three children, in equal shares.”
- “I give my son John the right to live in the home for two years, after which it shall be sold and the proceeds divided among all my children.”
- “I direct my executor to sell the home and distribute the proceeds to my named beneficiaries.”
In these cases, the executor has a fiduciary duty to follow the will’s instructions. While disagreements can still arise among beneficiaries, the will provides a clear legal path forward. Without it, the family is left to the default rules of the state, which rarely align with anyone’s wishes.
When There Is No Will: New York’s Intestacy Laws
When a New Yorker dies without a will, they are considered to have died “intestate.” In this situation, the state of New York does not guess what the person might have wanted. Instead, it imposes a rigid formula for asset distribution dictated by law. This is outlined in New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) § 4-1.1.
The statute sets a clear hierarchy for inheritance. If the deceased person (the “decedent”) has:
- A spouse and no children, the spouse inherits everything.
- A spouse and children, the spouse gets the first $50,000 and half the remainder. The children share the other half.
- Children and no spouse, the children inherit everything equally.
When children inherit a house this way, they typically take title as “tenants in common.” This means each child owns a distinct, fractional share of the property. It also means any one of them can force the sale of the property through a legal action called a partition sale. This is exactly the situation the Brooklyn siblings faced. The sister in California could have gone to court to compel the sale of the brownstone, forcing her brother out so she could get her inheritance in cash. It is a harsh outcome that thoughtful planning could have avoided.
The Overlooked Factor: How the Deed Is Titled
Sometimes, even a will does not control who gets the house. The single most important document in this analysis is often the deed itself. How a property is titled can override any instructions left in a will. This is a detail many people miss.
In New York, two common forms of co-ownership are:
Joint Tenants with Rights of Survivorship (JTWROS): If a deed is titled this way—for example, between a parent and one child—the property automatically passes to the surviving joint owner upon the other’s death. It happens by operation of law and does not pass through the deceased’s estate. The will has no effect on it. I have had to explain to families that their parent’s will, which promised to divide the house equally, was irrelevant because the deed named only one sibling as a joint tenant. That one sibling inherited the entire house, leaving the others with nothing.
Tenants in Common (TIC): This is the default form of co-ownership unless JTWROS is specified. Each owner has a distinct, separate share. When one owner dies, their share does not automatically go to the other owners. Instead, it passes to the beneficiaries named in their will or, if there is no will, to their heirs according to intestacy law.
Understanding the deed is not a minor detail—it is the foundation of any plan for your real estate. Intentional planning ensures that the way your property is titled aligns with your wishes for your legacy.
The fate of a family home is too important to be left to chance or the cold, impersonal rules of state law. A deliberate plan provides clarity, minimizes conflict, and allows your family to focus on grieving and healing rather than fighting over assets in Surrogate’s Court. Stewardship.
If you own property and are uncertain about how it would be distributed, a good first step is to locate the deed. We can then schedule a meeting to review the document and discuss how its legal structure fits into your family’s long-term goals.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.
